Comments on: Thomas & Friends: Go, Train, Go! http://thomasandfriendsonline.com/thomas-friends-go-train-go Thomas & Friends Wooden Railway, Trains, Toys, Merchandise Tue, 07 Feb 2012 02:27:51 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: Karen K. Hart http://thomasandfriendsonline.com/thomas-friends-go-train-go/comment-page-1#comment-171 Karen K. Hart Fri, 29 Jan 2010 16:05:42 +0000 http://thomasandfriendsonline.com/thomas-friends-go-train-go#comment-171 The board book is pretty sturdy, so it should withstand plenty of readings. The illustrations are surprisingly detailed for their style. The text flows nicely; it has a good rhythm. There are a lot of things to talk about here: a hat that flies off, a cow who moos at Thomas as Thomas peeps back, and a dog beside the tracks. The fact that the whole story is about Thomas taking a judge to a train show means that a great variety of engines appear at the end, and Harvey shows up on an earlier page. <br />If you are bothered by the use of "slow" (as opposed to "slowly") as an adverb, you might want to skip this one. Thomas "goes slow" repeatedly. <br />Additional note: I didn't realize that the board book was an abridged version of Go, Train, Go! until my son got the full version for Christmas. The two books have very different rhythms, and the full version has quite a few more pages. There's even a goat in the longer book, but there's no goat in the board book. Initially, I liked the rhythm of the board book better, but the other version is growing on me. Rating: 4 / 5 The board book is pretty sturdy, so it should withstand plenty of readings. The illustrations are surprisingly detailed for their style. The text flows nicely; it has a good rhythm. There are a lot of things to talk about here: a hat that flies off, a cow who moos at Thomas as Thomas peeps back, and a dog beside the tracks. The fact that the whole story is about Thomas taking a judge to a train show means that a great variety of engines appear at the end, and Harvey shows up on an earlier page.

If you are bothered by the use of “slow” (as opposed to “slowly”) as an adverb, you might want to skip this one. Thomas “goes slow” repeatedly.

Additional note: I didn’t realize that the board book was an abridged version of Go, Train, Go! until my son got the full version for Christmas. The two books have very different rhythms, and the full version has quite a few more pages. There’s even a goat in the longer book, but there’s no goat in the board book. Initially, I liked the rhythm of the board book better, but the other version is growing on me.
Rating: 4 / 5

]]> By: Denali http://thomasandfriendsonline.com/thomas-friends-go-train-go/comment-page-1#comment-170 Denali Fri, 29 Jan 2010 14:17:57 +0000 http://thomasandfriendsonline.com/thomas-friends-go-train-go#comment-170 My daugher (18 months) loves this book. She even refers to it as the "go" book. I like to read it by mimicking the speed of the text. I slow down when it says "slow slow slow" and I read it fast when the train is moving fast. From an adult's perspective, I would have preferred it to be written better, but it's fine for a child. However, I don't think it necessarily teaches bad grammar. <br /> <br />Now that I know this is the abridged version, I'll have to look for the full version. That probably explains why the story seems incomplete (especially at the end). Rating: 4 / 5 My daugher (18 months) loves this book. She even refers to it as the “go” book. I like to read it by mimicking the speed of the text. I slow down when it says “slow slow slow” and I read it fast when the train is moving fast. From an adult’s perspective, I would have preferred it to be written better, but it’s fine for a child. However, I don’t think it necessarily teaches bad grammar.

Now that I know this is the abridged version, I’ll have to look for the full version. That probably explains why the story seems incomplete (especially at the end).
Rating: 4 / 5

]]> By: Sherri R. Patrick http://thomasandfriendsonline.com/thomas-friends-go-train-go/comment-page-1#comment-169 Sherri R. Patrick Fri, 29 Jan 2010 13:10:36 +0000 http://thomasandfriendsonline.com/thomas-friends-go-train-go#comment-169 This book has a great flow/rhythm to it. My little one has memorized many of the phases. It's a nice short read with plenty of opportunity to animate your voice for extra enjoyment. Rating: 5 / 5 This book has a great flow/rhythm to it. My little one has memorized many of the phases. It’s a nice short read with plenty of opportunity to animate your voice for extra enjoyment.
Rating: 5 / 5

]]>